The question of synthetic chemicals in natural products is a difficult one. Firstly, for a product to truly be "natural", it shouldn't contain synthetics, although there are some that argue all things are technically natural.
I personally refuse to use petroleum-derived substances in the body products I make - not only for the questionable safety of some of them, but also because petroleum is a non-renewable resource. It takes millions of years to form and we are gobbling it up at an incredible rate, which doesn't combine well with the fact that there is only so much to be had.
As is mentioned on this site, it is very important to note that just because something is natural does not mean that it is safe. Some of the most toxic things around are considered natural. Essential oils, in particular, need to be used with a healthy amount of respect, caution and knowledge. When it comes to herbs, I don't think they should be sold at Longs, Safeway, et cetera because the only people who buy herbs there are not very educated about them. The quality is generally low (so people think they don't work) and those purchasing them do not have enough herbal knowledge to keep themselves away from potential harm, in particular the elderly. The example that comes to mind is the situation where someone on prescription anticoagulants takes Gingko because somewhere (TV and advertising) they heard it is good for your memory.
The one area that troubles me the most in the synthetic vs. natural debate is when it comes to the fragrances of over-harvested, endangered or otherwise compromised plant species. I don't use sandalwood or rosewood in my products for this reason. Would it be appropriate to use sandalwood fragrance as a replacement? Possibly so, although it is obviously not equivalent, nor would it have the therapeutic qualities of the real thing. Though, if it is well enough crafted, it might make a pleasant scent. I also wonder if it is appropriate to cut down entire trees so that I can have a nice smelling lotion or bath salt?
My dad asked me one day, if we switched all of the scented body and other products around to natural fragrances, what would become of our plant populations? To be honest, I don't know. Maybe the more fitting question is why do we need everything to be so smelly? Most people's sense of smell has been burnt out by overload. For a dose of what we're dealing with, just walk down the cleaning isle of your local grocery store. I like what Mindy Green (aromatherapist) said in a class I took from her - the purpose of perfume is not to fill up a room, but to have just enough scent to draw someone closer in to you.
For the record, I love wonderful smells, but I have an equal distaste for unpleasant or conventionally perfumy ones. Despite my love of natural fragrance, I still don't need to have every single product I buy for myself and my home to have an overwhelming scent to it.
I guess the gist of my entry is that there are pros and cons to both sides on many levels. Those of us that have interest in such things need to seriously consider the arguments and make up our own minds. As you see, I choose not to use synthetic chemicals or petroleum products in anything I make, but it is something I have thought about at great length and will continue to. It is important not to be puritanical, simply for the sake of doing so. When presented with new information, our opinions should be reevaluated and adjusted, if appropriate.
The best thing I can do is educate those around me and get them to thinking about their purchases. They can buy as they like, but at least they will be doing it consciously.
Erika Barnes
Sequoia Botanicals
Posted by sequoiabotanicals
at 12:00 PM EDT
Updated: Friday, June 3, 2005 12:02 PM EDT
Don't be fooled into thinking that essential oils are safe, just because they're natural. There are many essential oils that cause skin reactions on both normal and sensitive skin. Most can be used in very small amounts, but don't go smothering yourself in oil, just because it's natural. Talk to a professional or do some safety research on that product. Scent related reactions are uncommon in essential oils.
I have decided to begin this blog with Neroli one the most precious and beautiful oils available.